论文标题

5/6G:未来的网络还是截面网络?

5/6G: Networks of the Future or Defuturing Networks?

论文作者

Cano, Cristina, March, Hug

论文摘要

能源效率是5/6G网络可持续性解决方案的核心。我们认为这是对可持续性的过于狭窄的看法,因为它忽略了这些网络刺激的交通需求增加的影响以及对该需求所需的其他设备的需求。希望是减少网络运营能源消耗的技术能够弥补交通需求的增加。但是,挑战不仅仅减少网络所需的功能,而且尚不清楚更高的能源效率是否能够应对需求的增加。需要与5/6G网络部署有关的更多设备可能会产生重要的环境影响:i)材料提取的压力增加,这意味着社会环境冲突,生态系统破坏和流离失所,ii)更多的制造和运输,对温室气体发射和污染产生影响; iii)增加了处理此类设备组件的处置复杂性和挑战。通过将我们对可持续性的看法扩展到包括上述经常被忽略的含义,我们能够确定需要重新考虑的5/6G网络的设计要求和技术支柱。我们还设计了新的道路,以应对这些挑战。我们认为,考虑旨在明确满足用户需求的替代应用程序和要求至关重要,而不是不断地创造新的需求。我们还声称,在新硬件的生产中承认物质限制至关重要,从而促进了未来网络开发中的改造和模块化设计。本文的结论表明,现在是时候重新考虑移动网络开发过程,以使其与当前的环境目标保持一致,以应对世界正在经历的气候紧急情况。

Energy efficiency is at the core of sustainability solutions for 5/6G networks. We argue this is a too narrow perspective on sustainability, as it ignores the effects of the increased traffic demand these networks stimulate and the need for additional equipment that this demand requires. The hope is that techniques to reduce the network's energy consumption in operation will be able to compensate for increases in traffic demand. However, there are more challenges than just reducing the energy that the network requires to function and it is not clear whether higher energy efficiency will be able to cope with increasing demand. The need for more equipment related to deployment of 5/6G networks may result in important environmental impacts: i) increased pressures on material extraction, which imply socio-environmental conflicts, ecosystem destruction and displacement, ii) more manufacturing and shipment, with effects on greenhouse gas emissions and pollution; iii) increased disposal complexities and challenges to recycle components of such equipments. By extending our view on sustainability to include the aforementioned often ignored implications, we are able to identify design requirements and technical pillars of 5/6G networks that need to be rethought. We also devise new paths forward to address these challenges. We argue that it is crucial to think of alternative applications and requirements that aim to serve user demands explicitly, instead of incessantly creating new needs. We also claim that acknowledging material limitations in the production of new hardware is critical, promoting retrofitting and modular design in future network development. The conclusions of this article show that it is time to start rethinking the course of mobile network development in order to align it to current environmental objectives to tackle the climate emergency the world is experiencing.

扫码加入交流群

加入微信交流群

微信交流群二维码

扫码加入学术交流群,获取更多资源