论文标题

海平面上升和持续适应:残余损害的增长速度快于保护费用

Sea-level rise and continuous adaptation: residual damage rises faster than the protection costs

论文作者

Rybski, Diego, Prahl, Boris F., Boettle, Markus, Kropp, Jürgen P.

论文摘要

损坏成本曲线 - 将天然危害与其物理幅度相关的典型损害 - 代表了气候变化影响评估所需的必不可少成分。可以估计,将这种曲线与所考虑的自然危害,预期损害和相关风险的发生概率相结合。在这里,我们研究了最近发布的沿海洪水的城市规模伤害成本曲线,并证明只能从功能中获得哪些见解。因此,我们包括保护成本曲线 - 将保护城市免受一定程度的自然危害所必需的典型投资成本(与上述损害成本曲线相似,并且与上述损害成本曲线相似,这是一定程度上的自然危害。具体而言,我们激励对数逻辑功能,该功能在下端表现出幂律增加,并将其适合成本曲线。如预期的那样,保护最大损失(通常是大城市)的城市也更为昂贵。此外,我们研究了持续适应的理想化案例,即\ \在与海平面上升相同的速度下的保护水平提高,并将相关成本与超过保护的极端事件造成的残留损害进行比较。根据合适的指数,我们发现在几乎所有城市中,残差损害的上升速度都比保护成本快。提高沿海保护会导致欺骗性的安全。

Damage cost curves -- relating the typical damage of a natural hazard to its physical magnitude -- represent an indispensable ingredient necessary for climate change impact assessments. Combining such curves with the occurrence probability of the considered natural hazard, expected damage and related risk can be estimated. Here we study recently published city scale damage cost curves for coastal flooding and demonstrate which insights can be gained from the functions only. Therefore, we include protection cost curves -- relating the typical investment costs necessary to protect a city against a natural hazard of certain magnitude -- which are analogous to and consistent with the above mentioned damage cost curves. Specifically, we motivate log-logistic functions, which exhibit a power-law increase at the lower end, and fit them to the cost curves. As expected, cities with large maximum potential loss (typically large cities) are also more costly to protect. Moreover, we study the idealized case of continuous adaptation, i.e.\ increasing protection levels in the same pace as sea-level rise, and compare the associated costs with residual damage from extreme events exceeding the protection. Based on the fitted exponents we find that in almost all cities the residual damage rises faster than the protection costs. Raising coastal protection can lead to lull oneself in a deceptive safety.

扫码加入交流群

加入微信交流群

微信交流群二维码

扫码加入学术交流群,获取更多资源