论文标题

入门物理学的性别表现差异:一所大土地大学的研究

Gendered Performance Differences in Introductory Physics: A Study from a Large Land-Grant University

论文作者

Dew, Matthew, Perry, Jonathan, Ford, Lewis, Bassichis, William, Erukhimova, Tatiana

论文摘要

研究入门物理学的性别差异的研究表明,关于概念评估的性别差距有共识。但是,在考试中性别绩效差异时,这个故事并不清楚。这项研究检查了入门物理课程中的期中和期末考试中是否存在性别差异,并且这种差异是否与最终课程成绩的性别差异相关。这项研究的人口包括10,000多名学生在2007年春季至2019年春季之间的基于代数和微积分的介绍性物理学课程。我们发现在四个课程中只有一个小字母等级的较小但统计学上的差异很小,具有较弱的效果大小:基于代数的机制。通过查看期中考试成绩,在四个课程中的三个课程中,某些考试中有统计学上的显着差异,基于代数的电力和磁性是例外。在所有具有统计学意义的情况下,效果大小很小或弱,表明考试和最终字母等级的表现并不强烈取决于性别。作为研究性别差异的附加维度,我们研究了在考虑教师性别时是否存在差异。此外,2019年秋季对两个介绍性序列的1,600多名学生进行了问卷调查,以探讨学生对表现,班级贡献和包容性的看法。我们观察到学生对按性别进行分组时对表现的看法和贡献之间的差异,但对包容感的看法没有差异。

Studies examining gender differences in introductory physics show a consensus when it comes to a gender gap on conceptual assessments; however, the story is not as clear when it comes to differences in gendered performance on exams. This study examined whether gendered differences exist on midterm and final exams in introductory physics courses and if such differences were correlated with a gender difference in final course grades. The population for this study included more than 10,000 students enrolled in algebra- and calculus-based introductory physics courses between spring 2007 and spring 2019. We found a small but statistically significant difference, with a weak effect size, in final letter grades for only one out of four courses: algebra-based mechanics. By looking at midterm exam grades, statistically significant differences were noted for some exams in three out of four courses, with algebra-based electricity and magnetism being the exception. In all statistically significant cases, the effect size was small or weak, indicating that performance on exams and final letter grades was not strongly dependent on gender. As an added dimension examining gendered differences, we investigated if differences exist when accounting for instructor gender. Additionally, a questionnaire was administered in fall 2019 to more than 1,600 students in both introductory sequences to explore students' perceptions of performance, class contributions, and inclusion. We observed some differences between students' perception of their performance and contribution when grouped by gender, but no difference on perception of inclusion.

扫码加入交流群

加入微信交流群

微信交流群二维码

扫码加入学术交流群,获取更多资源